Jack Yan
Global  |  Leadership  |  Experience  |  Media  |  Videos
Blog  |  Contact
 
  Follow me on Mastodon Follow me on Twitter Check out my Instagram account Follow me on Drivetribe Follow me on NewTumbl Follow me on Linkedin Follow me on Weibo Join my page on Facebook Subscribe to my blog’s RSS feed  

 

Share this page




Quick links


Surf to the online edition of Lucire





Add feeds



Get this blog via email
Enter your Email


Powered by FeedBlitz

Enter your email address:


Delivered by FeedBurner



 

The Persuader

My personal blog, started in 2006.



« | »

04.07.2011

What this Google-sceptic thought of Plus

A friend wanted an invitation to Google Plus, and since I received mine a few days ago when someone shared a story with me, I thought it might work if I shared a story with her.
   So, for half an hour today, I joined, with the view of sending her the invitation, and leaving as soon as I did that. Below is a cursory review without any analysis of Hangout or Sparks.
   First step: I made my profile public. Good news: I can still keep myself out of searches, according to Google, and I don’t have to give them a telephone number. Disturbing part: anyone with the URL to my profile can still find me. Since I have trust issues with Google—with good reason, this being the latest—I don’t believe them when they say they can keep me out of searches.
   Bad news: I don’t have a choice of URL for my profile.
   Signed in. Nice, clean interface. I actually like the look and feel. Everything seems workable though it took a while for me to find the Share feature up top.
   Poked around a bit. Glad that under Plus, you can liberate your data from Google with downloads should you decide to cancel your account (tempting).
   The account manager is better laid out than the former version.
   Less impressive: the fact that Google Plus is set to spam you by default. If you’re like me, you’d want to turn off all email and SMS notifications.

Google Plus spam settings

   Your Picasa album gets integrated with your Plus account, so the attribution might change. It doesn’t make much difference to me, since I have no photos on Picasa.
   Other than Picasa, it didn’t need changes to the terms and conditions, though I read them again when I made my profile public.
   Found I was followed by six people. Five real friends. One complete stranger.
   Since I have single strangers follow me on Buzz (which I don’t have), Contacts (which I don’t have) and Reader (which I don’t use), then I didn’t feel comfortable on Plus. I realize anyone can add you to their Circle and, like Twitter, that’s the point of it. I also realize I can share only with limited audiences.
   I admit that one good point is that no companies and organizations are on it yet, so your feed only has real people. But that’s what my A Small World account is for, and my 33 friends there.
   It’s fairly bug-free but so was Facebook, once upon a time. But you still can’t opt out of seeing Plus One links on other sites, despite Google’s claims.
   Still, why would I want to be on a website that gives me constant worry with every moment I am signed on to it? It just reminded me of the constant stream of weird anonymous users trying to check out my activity on those other Google services.
   And, right now, I can’t be arsed setting up new circles and all that jazz. I have followers’ lists on Twitter and four categories of “friends” on Facebook. On the latter, I am able to tailor my messages to each one of these groups.
   The sharing method didn’t work with my friend, so I deleted my Google Plus (with thanks to Andrew Carr-Smith for giving me earlier info on this). Quite a painless procedure, actually—unlike so many of Google’s other services, I didn’t need to close my account and delete all services associated with it. Google calls it a ‘downgrade’.
   Plus created a new folder on Picasa, which I had to delete manually there.
   I then put my profile back to normal, i.e. non-existent, other than my name. Funnily enough, Google allowed it, so there were no remnant data or any sign I had tried Plus—with the exception of my being unable to sign up to it when I now visit plus.google.com. I can now block the Plus cookie.
   To me, it’s no big loss. That was probably the most overhyped experience I have seen online since Google launched Chrome (a.k.a. the ‘Aw, snap!’ browser), and other than sheer speed, that left me totally unimpressed, too.
   Once the hype dies down, I don’t foresee this going anywhere (and yes, I am biased). It will get users, because a lot of people drink the Google Kool-Aid, but it’ll exist just like CNN and Fox News do. Till Google fixes up the privacy bugs it has for the existing services I use, I am extremely hesitant to add any more.

Related posts

Filed under: culture, internet, USA—Jack Yan @ 12.48

10 Responses to ‘What this Google-sceptic thought of Plus’

  1. Jenny says:

    Ah, I’ve been very interested to seeing what the hype was all about. I don’t think we need another Facebook, though, and I don’t really see this going anywhere either.

  2. Jack Yan says:

    It was very underwhelming. I know Chrome has its adherents, so I suspect those who go on to Plus will be the usual Google fanatics. If you aren’t drinking the Google Kool-Aid, it doesn’t offer much.

  3. jaklumen says:

    I’m simply interested because it is NOT Facebook. The negatives alone that I had with Facebook is just enough that I want to see what Google’s got.

    “If it ain’t broken, don’t fix it”… no, I found Facebook too broken for my purposes. And my rosy view of Google has faded enough:
    http://techswrite.wordpress.com/2011/07/03/why-cross-platform-is-a-misleading-concept/
    the gist being that I found some recent Linux offerings from Google buggy and not even properly integrated or a faithful port.

    I still say they are doing more for Linux than Microsoft will ever dare to do, but I assure you any rose-tinted glasses are gone.

    So, again, I would like to give Google+ a shot and if you happen to have an invite, well, please, send it my way. I’ll think of something to trade or you’ll have my heartfelt gratitude, whichever is appropriate.

  4. Jack Yan says:

    Sorry, Jak, I deleted my Google Plus account. When you do that, you automatically go to the back of the line and Google lets other folks come up front, which, I suppose, is fair enough.
       There’s actually no invitation mechanism. You can, however, share something with someone, and hope they get the invitation there. As I discovered, that doesn’t always hold true, either.

  5. jaklumen says:

    Yes, I see that now.

    I finally got in courtesy of Ross… and yes, it was by way of sharing something. But I don’t mind– what he shared did tell me a bit more about how things are operating, although I’ll never use the mobile app.

  6. Jack Yan says:

    Jak: it looks like, as of today, there is an invitation link.

  7. […] you wade through my juggernaut-ish train of thought, I thought Jack Yan summed up privacy concerns about Google Plus pretty well. Although Google repeats “Don’t be evil” almost like a religious mantra, they are […]

  8. […] you wade through my juggernaut-ish train of thought, I thought Jack Yan summed up privacy concerns about Google Plus pretty well. Although Google repeats “Don’t be evil” almost like a religious mantra, they are […]

  9. […] chance to make up their own minds. The only period I couldn’t sign in to Plus was immediately after my initial deletion or ‘downgrade’. If it were not for the profile threat made several days after that deletion, I would have […]

  10. […] yours is secret at present, Google’s position is: too bad.    As I discovered when I was playing around with Plus earlier this week, you can choose to make your profile invisible to the Google search engine. I do not know if […]

Leave a reply